Challenge Problem – the ANSWER

Hi everyone,

Here is the answer to yesterday’s challenge problem, the probability problem about catching fish.

First, there are 6 ways to catch the three fish in three casts, getting exactly one trout, one carp and one bass.

You could get the fish in any of these six orders:

TCB / TBC / CTB / CBT / BTC / BCT

Next you find the probability of getting one of these possibilities. Let’s take the first one, TCB.

Keep in mind that after you catch the first fish, the number of fish left goes down by one, to 11; after catching the second fish, the number of fish goes down to 10.

The probability for the TCB possibility is calculated by multiplying:  6/12 x 4/11 x 2/10 = 2/55

When you think about the five other ways to catch the fish, you’ll see that the order of the numerators changes, but the denominators remain 12, 11, 10. So the probability for catching the three fish in any of the six ways is always the same:  2/55.

To get the probability for all six catches, just multiply the probability of one catch by 6:

6/1 x 2/55  =  12/55

And that is the answer: the probability of catching exactly one trout, one carp and one bass is 12/55, which works out to about 21.8%, meaning that this should happen a little more than 1/5 of the time.

I didn’t see anyone submit any answers, but feel free to send them in. Remember that I will post only the correct answers, so no one has to worry about seeing an incorrect answer posted.

Have a great day!

—  Josh

Keep In Touch!

Follow us on Facebook & Twitter, or fill in your email address below to receive exclusive discounts and news from Singing Turtle Press:

One Response to “Challenge Problem – the ANSWER”

  1. Michelle says:

    …keep it coming…love your site!!!!
    You do a great job of explaining things so that it is so easy to understand. …and so practical.
    thank you, Josh!
    By the way, will you be at the NCTM Conference in San Diego. You really should present there. I don’t recall how I found your site to begin with. Was it at the NCTM Conference a while back?

    #